Health care integration has long been touted as a panacea for reining in health care costs and boosting quality of care.
But integrated health systems appear to be failing on both fronts, according to the results of a new nationwide study led by researchers at Harvard and the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER).
Instead, the analysis finds marginally better care at significantly higher costs for patients seen in health systems, compared to those at independent practices or hospitals.
The results of the study are published Jan. 24 in JAMA.
In recent decades, health systems in the United States have grown exponentially in size and market share through mergers and acquisitions of physician practices and hospitals and the joining of separate health systems.
During those years, proponents of consolidation have argued that physicians and hospitals working together in integrated, coordinated systems would not only provide better care for patients, but would do so more efficiently than independent physician practices and hospitals, driving quality of care up while holding spending steady and even driving costs down.
“One of the key arguments for hospital mergers and practice acquisition was that health systems would deliver better-value care for patients. This study provides the most comprehensive evidence yet that this isn’t happening,” said study first author Nancy Beaulieu, a research associate in the Department of Health Care Policy in the Blavatnik Institute at Harvard Medical School.
Today, these systems are responsible for a large proportion of the medical care delivered in the United States. Some of them employ thousands of physicians, while others are much smaller and rooted in local communities. But questions about just how much care is delivered by such systems, or how good that care is compared with care delivered outside of systems, have lingered unanswered.
Despite their impact on population health and the economy, little is known about the actual performance of integrated health organizations, the study authors noted.
Research in this area has been hindered by the lack of detailed data that allow a meaningful examination of performance or even measuring the scale and scope of care delivery within health systems. The current analysis is believed to be the first comprehensive national study to compare outcomes between patients receiving care within health systems and outside of them, including patients with private insurance as well as traditional Medicare.
The analysis included a total of 580 health systems that accounted for 40 percent of physicians and 84 percent of general acute care hospital beds. Academic and large nonprofit systems accounted for a majority of system physicians (80 percent) and system hospital beds (64 percent).
System hospitals were larger than hospitals that were not part of a system, with 67 percent of system hospitals having more than 100 beds, while only 23 percent of nonsystem hospitals having more than 100 beds. System physician practices likewise were more likely to have more than 100 physicians compared with nonsystem practices (74 percent vs. 12 percent). Integrated systems delivered primary care to 41 percent of traditional Medicare beneficiaries; which does not include people enrolled in Medicare Advantage programs.
Next, the researchers analyzed the quality and cost of care delivered within systems. Their findings suggest that patients whose primary care physicians are part of health systems, on average, receive marginally better care and report slightly better experiences with the health care delivery system, compared with patients whose primary care physicians are part of independent practices.
This is the case even though many patients with nonsystem primary care providers also receive some of their care in hospitals or specialist practices that are part of a health system. However, care in systems came at a much higher price, contributing to higher overall spending on health care, the research showed.
Prices for services from physicians and hospitals within health systems were significantly higher than the prices of services from independent physicians and hospitals, the study found. Physician services delivered within health systems cost between 12 percent and 26 percent more, compared with independent practices. System-based hospital services cost 31 percent more, on average, compared with care delivered by independent hospitals.
Small differences in quality combined with large differences in cost of care suggests that health systems have not, on average, realized their potential for better care at equal or lower cost, the researchers said.
Members of the research team have compiled a database from various sources to help characterize these health systems and to link claims data with information on health care providers in and out of health systems. The database, housed at NEBR, will be made available for free to other researchers in the near future.
More information on the health systems and provider database and research conducted as part of the health systems project can be found at NBER Health Systems Project.
The researchers noted that the new database provides a crucial foundation for future research that could help identify areas where integrated health systems may be outperforming independent practices and hospitals or guide efforts for health systems still hoping to achieve the potential benefits of consolidation, while avoiding increased costs.
“There’s no question that large, sophisticated health systems have benefits over independent systems,” said study author David Cutler, the Otto Eckstein Professor of Applied Economics at Harvard. “Big systems tend to be less vulnerable to economic downturns and they can provide specialized care that would be difficult to maintain in smaller systems. But the hoped-for cost savings benefits of integrated health systems have not yet materialized.”
Authorship, support, disclosures
Co-authors on the study include Michael Chernew, J. Michael McWilliams, Mary Beth Landrum, and Andrew Hicks of HMS. Maurice Dalton, Angela Yutong Gu, Michael Briskin, Rachel Wu, Zakaria El Amrani El Idrissi, and Helene Machado of NBER also contributed to this research.
This study was supported by a grant from the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHRQ) U19HS024072.
See the article for a full list of disclosures.
How to Measure Moisture Content in Rice
How to Measure Moisture Content in Rice By Fahad A. Khan Moisture content is basically the weight of water that is contained in the rice or paddy which is expressed in percentage. This is referred to the wet basis that means the total weight of the grain inclusive of water. Why is it important? It... Readmore
Options After Completing Bachelor of Arts (BA)
Options After Completing Bachelor of Arts (BA) By Rakhi Singh Kaur Completing a graduation can be termed as a penultimate step of your educational career, at least, regular formal educational career. Students after completing their graduation often get confused as to what exactly are the options go... Readmore
All About Intermittent Fasting
All About Intermittent Fasting By Blake Pennock Intermittent Fasting (IF) refers to dietary eating patterns that involve not eating or severely restricting calories for a prolonged period of time. There are many different subgroups of intermittent fasting each with individual variation in the durat... Readmore
Getting To A Place To Breathe Again
Getting To A Place To Breathe Again By Ashley Thompson I grew up in the church, and experienced God move in many ways. It was so much easier to experience God when I was younger, the more I grew up the more difficult it became. The more tainted my spirit became, the harder it was for me to dig to f... Readmore
Exercises and Workouts - Three Workout Musts To Avoid Injury
Exercises and Workouts - Three Workout Musts To Avoid Injury By Beverleigh H Piepers Do you exercise even when you are tired from lack of sleep? Do you take your eye off when you need to do a warm-up routine? If so, you could be setting yourself up for a workout injury. Let us face it, injuries suc... Readmore
What to Look for in a Car Audio
What to Look for in a Car Audio By Shalini Madhav If you want to boost the dashboard tech, then you need to pay some attention to the car audio. When you do this, then you will have a completely new experience. There are some features that you should concentrate on when you want to choose only the ... Readmore
New Book Teaches How to Attract Money Through Thought and Action
New Book Teaches How to Attract Money Through Thought and Action By Tyler Tichelaar Nearly a century ago, a brilliant man, Napoleon Hill, decided to study how the most successful people in America-people like Henry Ford, Thomas Edison, and Andrew Carnegie-came up with their great ideas and became s... Readmore
Book Review of "Permanent Happiness" by Iyabo Ojikutu MD
Book Review of "Permanent Happiness" by Iyabo Ojikutu MD By Paige Lovitt "Permanent Happiness" by Iyabo Ojikutu, MD, is a beautifully written guide to help you live a peaceful life. Tying together the link between our physical and spiritual lives, Dr. Ojikutu offers three steps to help us become mo... Readmore
Understanding Browser Games
Understanding Browser Games By Shalini Madhav Browser games can be defined as computer games that are played on the internet through web browsers. They can be run by making use of the standard plug-ins and web technologies. The creation also has to include the standard web technologies. They includ... Readmore
The Advantages of a Motorcycle Track Day
The Advantages of a Motorcycle Track Day By Amy Hall If you're a motorcyclist, you are familiar will the thrill you experience being in your own world, on a completely empty and winding road, enjoying a smooth ride. As a rider, you take a lot of risks, riding on the streets and public access roads,... Readmore
No comments:
Post a Comment
Informations From: Dunia Aneh Blog 89